Where Did Chili Originate From. Click to see full answer. By the time columbus made it to the new world, chili peppers were already fully domesticated by the indigenous population.

George todoroff of jackson coney island restaurant in jackson, mich., claimed in 1914 he “created his famous recipe for coney island chili sauce, and the coney island hot dog was born.”. In 1888, experiments began for cross breeding of chili plants. Other europeans thought that its origin was india, because the cuisine was too spicy for their palates.